 
 
	** GENERATING FIGURE 2
 
 	clear
	set scheme lean1
	version 16.1
	graph set window fontface "Times New Roman"
	cd "~"
		
		 
	import excel "EBA VTFE results.xlsx", sheet("VTNL") firstrow case(lower) clear
	drop if models==.
	destring keep, replace
	 
	keep if keep==1
	
	keep variable lower_eb upper_eb mean 
	
	sort mean
	
	gen long newid = _N - _n + 1 
	sort newid 
	
		gen order=.
		
		  
		drop if variable=="Population , ln"

		replace order=12 if var== "Concurrent" 
		replace order=11 if var== "Compulsory voting"	
		replace order=10 if var== "Proportional representation" 	
		replace order=9 if var=="Spending decentralisation" 			
		replace order=8 if var== "1919-1994"			
		replace order=7 if var== "Inflation"	
		replace order=6 if var== "Lagged DV"	
		replace order=5 if var== "Closeness/competitiveness"	
		replace order=4 if var== "Sufferage"			
 		replace order=3 if var== "Economic globalisation"
 		replace order=2 if var== "Time trend" 
		replace order=1 if var== "GNI per capita, ln (const 2010 USD)"
	  
	  
	 	  label define var2 	12 	"Concurrent"	///
								11 	"Compulsory voting" ///
								10 	"PR" ///
								9	"Spending decent." /// 
								8	"Years 1945-94" ///
								7	"Inflation" ///
								6	"Lagged D.V." ///
								5	"Closeness/compet." ///
								4	"Sufferage" ///
								3	"Econ. globaliz." ///
								2	"Time trend"	///
								1	"GNI pc, const. (ln)"
 
	 
				label value order  var2
	 
	 
	 
	 	    twoway (rspike lower_eb upper_eb order ,   horizontal	///
			msize(small) lwidth(vthin) lcolor(gs8)), ///
			xline(0, lcolor(cranberry) lwidth(vthin)) ///  
			xlabel(-40(5)25, format(%9.0f) labsize(small)) ///
			xtitle("Coefficient", size(small)) ///
			ylabel(#23,   valuelabel angle(zero) tlc(none) labsize(small)) ///
			ytitle("") ///
			name(coef, replace) || ///
			scatter order mean  ,   msize(tiny)  msymbol(sh) mcolor(gs2) legend(off)	
			graph save vtfe_sign.gph, replace
